Exotic Car Rentals in Islip, NY

Doorstep delivery across Islip Village, South Bay Avenue, Brookwood Hall, Oakdale, and Great River. Planeside pickup at Long Island MacArthur Airport (ISP) in 10 minutes with Modern Aviation, or Republic Airport (FRG) in 25. Mercedes-AMG G63, Porsche Cayenne Turbo, Range Rover Sport SV, BMW M8 Competition, and Lamborghini Urus ready for same-day booking.

Exotic car rentals delivered in Islip, NY
Concierge delivery in Islip, NY

Islip Village (ZIP 11751) median household income sits at $116,350 with the broader Town of Islip at $130,132. That outpaces the New York State median by roughly 42 percent and anchors a South Shore corridor of 1880s to 1920s Gilded Age estates, Great South Bay waterfront compounds, and the Nicoll family’s historic Brookwood Hall grounds.

BluStreet delivers exotic cars across every Islip neighborhood. Islip Village core for Main Street arrivals, South Bay Avenue for waterfront estates with deep-water docks, Brookwood Hall and the Nicoll corridor for historic plantings, Oakdale for the Bourne and Vanderbilt estate grounds, and Great River for Bayard Cutting Arboretum’s doorstep. Pickup ranges from doorstep concierge to planeside staging at Modern Aviation’s Long Island MacArthur (ISP) FBO just 10 minutes north for private-jet clients.

Clients book our Mercedes-AMG G63, Porsche Cayenne Turbo, Range Rover Sport SV, BMW M8 Competition, and Lamborghini Urus for weddings at the Bourne Mansion and the Mansion at Timber Point, galas at Bayard Cutting Arboretum, member events at Southward Ho Country Club and Timber Point, Fire Island ferry weekends out of Captain Bill’s in Bay Shore, and daily chauffeur runs into Manhattan via the Southern State Parkway and Belt Parkway.

Ready to Reserve in Islip?

Browse our full fleet or call our concierge team for availability and a personalized quote.

Exotic Cars Available in Islip, NY

Browse our current inventory. 183 exotic vehicles available for concierge delivery to Islip.

View All 183 Vehicles

Exotic Car Rental Services in Islip

Every BluStreet service is available with door-to-door delivery to Islip, NY and surrounding areas.

The Islip Estate Sections We Deliver To

Doorstep concierge delivery to every neighborhood, with current home-price ranges and local notes.

Islip Village Historic Core

Montauk Highway and Main Street corridor, walkable to La Grange Inn and the LIRR station, 1880s to 1920s estate homes anchor the block.

$750,000 to $2,500,000

South Bay Avenue Waterfront

Bulkheaded canal homes with deep-water docks on the Great South Bay, five minutes to Sayville ferry and Bay Shore's Fire Island Ferry terminals.

$1,400,000 to $4,000,000

Brookwood Hall / Nicoll Estate Section

Historic Nicoll family land surrounding Brookwood Hall gardens, mature plantings, close to Bayard Cutting Arboretum.

$900,000 to $2,800,000

Oakdale / Idle Hour Corridor

Former Vanderbilt and Bourne estate grounds, Dowling College campus, LIU Post feeder blocks and Bourne Mansion event grounds.

$850,000 to $3,500,000

Great River

Hamlet bordering Timber Point and Bayard Cutting Arboretum, horse properties and waterfront compounds along the Connetquot River.

$900,000 to $4,500,000

Planeside Pickup for Islip Flyers

Pre-staged at the FBO before your scheduled landing. Vehicle waiting planeside with keys ready at the general aviation terminal.

Luxury car planeside at the nearest private jet airport serving Islip
Planeside pickup serving Islip
ISP

Long Island MacArthur Airport

8-12 min · 5.5-7 mi

Closest private jet terminal to Islip Village, Modern Aviation operates the primary FBO (acquired the former Sheltair facility in 2022) with US Customs on the ramp for international arrivals. We pre-stage planeside 30 minutes before scheduled landing, keys ready for immediate departure to your estate.

FBO: Modern Aviation ISP · NY Jet
FRG

Republic Airport Farmingdale

20-30 min · 14-17 mi

Long Island's premier general-aviation airport with four full-service FBOs. We meet private jets at Sheltair's $55M complex or Atlantic Aviation's hangar for clients routing through Nassau-side Farmingdale. Southern State Parkway puts you at your Islip door in under 30 minutes.

FBO: Sheltair FRG · Atlantic Aviation FRG · Modern Aviation FRG · Republic Jet Center
JFK

John F. Kennedy International

45-70 min · 40-45 mi

International long-haul and commercial pickups via Southern State Parkway to the Belt Parkway. Private aviation clients served at Sheltair, Signature, or Modern Aviation FBOs. Allow 90 plus minutes in weekday rush hour.

FBO: Sheltair JFK · Signature Flight Support · Modern Aviation

Delivery to Islip's Members-Only Clubs

We stage at the member-entrance circle at your scheduled arrival time. Chauffeur handoff available for member events, weddings, and club galas.

Luxury car at a private club in Islip
Member-entrance staging at private clubs in Islip

Southward Ho Country Club

Bay Shore, NY 11706

Founded 1923, 18-hole championship course on the Great South Bay, full country club with tennis, pool, and member dining five minutes west of Islip Village.

Timber Point Country Club

398 Great River Rd, Great River, NY 11739

27-hole seaside Harry Colt and C.H. Alison design dating to 1925, historic C.H. Thorne estate clubhouse overlooking the Great South Bay.

Bergen Point Country Club

69 Bergen Ave, West Babylon, NY 11704

William F. Mitchell 18-hole course, full catering operation, 10 minutes southwest of Islip Village.

The Hamlet Golf and Country Club

1 Clubhouse Dr, Commack, NY 11725

Private Long Island club with meticulously conditioned course and member events, 20 minutes north of Islip Village.

Bay Shore Yacht Club

Bay Shore, NY 11706

Great South Bay member yacht club with tender service to Fire Island, hosts summer regattas and member dock-side dining.

Why Islip Clients Book BluStreet

Convenient Pickup Across the Town of Islip

Premium Fleet Selection and pickup throughout Islip and nearby South Shore communities, powered by our Deer Park headquarters for quick turnaround.

MacArthur Airport Friendly

Need a rental timed around ISP? We coordinate deliveries around arrivals and departures for executive travel, family visits, and weekend plans.

Full Fleet Access

Choose from 50+ exotic and luxury vehicles including Lamborghini, Ferrari, Rolls Royce, Bentley, McLaren, Mercedes-AMG G63, Porsche, and luxury SUVs.

Inspected and Detailed Before Delivery

Every vehicle is maintained and detailed at our Deer Park facility before it goes out, so it arrives clean, documented, and ready to drive.

24/7 BluStreet Concierge support

Our team is available around the clock during your rental. Need to extend or adjust timing? Call (646) 480-1680 anytime.

Perfect for Events and Content

Weddings, proms, birthdays, photo shoots, and brand content. We help you pick the right car and plan the timing so everything lands right.

The Signature Drives From Islip

Montauk Highway (Route 27A)

Historic South Shore artery through Islip Village, Oakdale, Sayville, and the Hamptons approaches.

Ocean Parkway

Barrier-island parkway from Robert Moses Causeway east past Fire Island, iconic Atlantic Ocean views.

Islip's History of Hosting Notable Guests

Sagtikos Manor

Montauk Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Listed on the National Register of Historic Places, 1697 manor house that hosted General George Washington during his 1790 Long Island tour.

Bayard Cutting Arboretum

440 Montauk Hwy, Great River, NY 11739

691-acre former Bayard Cutting estate, specimen trees, Frederick Law Olmsted-designed grounds, historic Tudor Revival manor house.

Islip Grange

20 Broadway Ave, Sayville, NY 11782

12-acre living-history park at Montauk Highway and Broadway, repository for Islip Town historic structures relocated for preservation.

Jacob Ockers House

Montauk Hwy, Oakdale, NY 11769

Only town-owned structure on the National Register of Historic Places in Islip, 19th-century home of the Oakdale clam baron.

La Grange Inn

499 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795

1750s stagecoach inn, one of the oldest continuously operating restaurant buildings on Long Island, highlighted on the Historic Islip Trail.

What Islip Clients Say

Absolutely the best of the best! Never been happier with a business. The people who work here are amazing. The owners great! Loveeee the cars. This was such a great experience. We will absolutely be back soon!

Google Review

Best rental car company New York. I rented it for my city hall marriage. Service was amazing since I arrived. Jasmine was exceptionally helpful from beginning to end. I rented a convertible Audi R8. This car was really smooth. The V10 was music to my ears. Revving up to 8500 RPM. Thanks to Justin, Moe and rest of the Blustreet Exotic for making this a unforgettable experience. I will love to rent from them again.

Google Review

Hi Justin, I just wanted to send a massive thank you for saving the day! When the original Lamborghini fell through right before the event due to a technical issue, your decision to upgrade us to a higher-end blue Lamborghini was incredible. Instead of leaving us stranded, you went above and beyond to provide the exact dream car we had hoped for, making it an unforgettable experience.We truly appreciate your amazing customer service and how you handled the situation with such professionalism. A special shout-out to Adam, our chauffeur, who was outstanding. He knew exactly where to take us for extra photo shoots, ensuring we captured the day perfectly. Highly recommend you and your amazing staff for going above and beyond to make things right!⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ — BluStreet Exotic Car Rentals

Google Review

Areas We Serve Near Islip

BluStreet delivers exotic cars to Islip, NY and all surrounding neighborhoods and towns.

Islip
East Islip
West Islip
Bay Shore
Brightwaters
Oakdale
Sayville
Central Islip
Brentwood Ronkonkoma
Bohemia
Holbrook
Hauppauge
Patchogue
Deer Park
Babylon Village
Lindenhurst
Copiague
Commack Smithtown Farmingdale Massapequa
Bethpage

Exotic Car Rentals Near Islip

Frequently Asked Questions About Exotic Car Rentals in Islip, NY

Yes. BluStreet provides pickup at our Deer Park location (delivery available as add-on) and picks up exotic and luxury vehicles throughout Islip and the surrounding Town of Islip communities. Because our fleet is based at our nearby Deer Park headquarters, we can provide pickup and reliable scheduling. Call (646) 480-1680 to check availability.
Absolutely. We frequently coordinate rentals around Long Island MacArthur Airport (ISP) for business travel, client visits, and weekend trips. Share your schedule and we’ll help time delivery and pickup properly. Call (646) 480-1680 to plan it.
Rates vary by vehicle, season, and dates. Rentals can start around $500/day for luxury SUVs and range up to $2,500+/day for ultra-premium models. The Lamborghini Urus often starts around $1,500/day. For an exact quote, call (646) 480-1680 with your dates.
You’ll need a valid driver’s license, full-coverage auto insurance that extends to rental and exotic vehicles, and a refundable security deposit on a major credit card. We’ll confirm requirements and walk you through everything before delivery.
The primary renter must be at least 18 years old with a valid license and full-coverage insurance that extends to exotic rentals. A refundable security deposit is required. Call (646) 480-1680 if you have questions about eligibility.
We provides pickup at our Deer Park location (delivery available as add-on) throughout the Town of Islip including Islip, East Islip, West Islip, Bay Shore, Brightwaters, Oakdale, Sayville, Central Islip, and Brentwood. We also deliver to nearby towns like Ronkonkoma, Bohemia, Holbrook, Hauppauge, and Patchogue. Call (646) 480-1680 to confirm your address.
Yes. Proms and weddings are two of our most popular rentals across Suffolk County. We can deliver early for photos, coordinate with your schedule, and handle pickup so it stays stress-free. Book early during peak season for the best selection. Call (646) 480-1680 to reserve.
For luxury and comfort, the Rolls Royce Cullinan, Rolls Royce Ghost, and Bentley models are top picks. For daily usability with serious presence, clients love the Lamborghini Urus and Mercedes-AMG G63. For a true supercar experience, the Lamborghini Huracan and Ferrari Spider are favorites.

Rent an Exotic Car in Islip Today

Door-to-door delivery, 50+ exotic vehicles, and 24/7 concierge support. Call us or browse the fleet to reserve your vehicle.